3.11.1. ADCOSSPA | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Results Presentation
* ADCOSSPA project targets a minimum weight reduction of 30% compared with aluminum reference. The next step after setting the final requirements for the composite structure that houses the electronics in a microsatellite is to define design and geometry. Generating an optimal design methodology for composite structure box (space housing type) and its application to optimize weight are important. The proposed design methodology should include constraints on radiation attenuation, natural frequency of vibration, structural integrity, electrical resistivity and also to limit distortions of shape generated by thermal load (heat cycles). Activity II.2. “Study on the design of the satellite electronic housing mechanical structure: CAD models” Within the Phase II of the ADCOSSPA project, activity II.2., three versions of CAD models were developed (Figure 2) for the box that houses the electronics in a microsatellite, having as reference the model ADPMS "Data and Power Management" from Proba 2 microsatellite. For the three design solutions, CADs rivets, such Tripo - mushroom head, as represented in Figure 1, were used for assembly that can be in aluminum, steel, copper. For the version 1 and 2 of CAD were used rivets 4.2 mm in diameter and for the third version rivets of 3.2 mm diameter bolts (figure 1). A first iteration of stress analysis was performed, in static regime, at loading of 6g on Ox, Oy and 11g on Oz, on the box structure (aluminum) without assembly with rivets (figure 3). It can be seen that maximum effort is 4.76 MPa at a load of 6g on Ox, Oy and 11g on Oz. Safety factor is 57.9, exceeding the value of the safety coefficient of 1.2 commonly accepted for space structures. Stress Calculations will continue with: 5. CONCLUSIONS: The objectives of Phase II: "Establish general requirements and design - II” have been achieved. Within the Activity II.1. “Requirements definition Part II”, was established a set of final requirements for the box that houses the electronics in a microsatellite, developed within the ADCOSSPA project from composite materials (Deliverable no. D1.1.1. "Final Report: Requirements definition"). Within the Activity II.2. “Study on the design of the satellite electronic housing mechanical structure: CAD models”, a documentation study regarding the mechanical structure design on the box that houses the electronics in a microsatellite was performed, resulting in the establishment of three solutions of CAD models for the box that houses the electronics a microsatellite (Deliverable no. D1.2. "Study: CAD models"). These results obtained in Phase II will be the basis for third phase activities " Structural design and analysis" in which: the optimum design(s) (CADs) for composite mechanical structure of the box will be chosen; numerical simulations FEM on the elements structure / models, will be performed; the test configurations will be selected, composite materials and structural design will be define, the mold design will be defined for the mechanical structure of housing electronics inside the satellite. Phase III : „Elaborated Study on final space functioning requirements” (21. 04. 2013- 20. 12. 2013) Objective : assessment and state of the operating/exploitation conditions for space structures and final requirements that the composite electronics housing structure of the microsatellite developed using autoclave technology within the ADCOSSPA project, must meet. Results : Space structures that are part of the satellite must be stiff, to assure dimensional stability at lunching stage and during on orbit operation. Materials with high thermal conductivity decrease the dimensional distortion issues by isothermalization of the structure from the two own vehicle shadows and from thermal cycling outside the Earth shadows. A low thermal coefficient of expansion decrees likewise the dimensional distortion. Mechanical strength is a critical parameter at lunching stage but once the satellite operates on orbit this become negligible due to low mechanical loading. The main on orbit loadings are thermal ones, generated by thermal cycling and keeping stiffness during on orbit operation (in case vibration induced by rotation, manoeuvres for the satellite). The displacement and natural frequency are proportional to the elasticity module of material(s). Nevertheless, integration of advanced materials in space vehicles is not an easy task, when looking at the critical lunching and functioning requirements. Low altitude orbit LEO (Low-Earth Orbit LEO), is the one of interest for the present study, the majority of satellites operates at these altitudes between 150 and 2000 km above the earth's surface. The space environment (LEO orbit) is characterized by: very low pressure (advanced vacuum: ~10-6 Torr), extreme temperatures (depending on the orientation of the material towards the sun, thermal cycles: [-70 ºC to + 100 ºC]), UV(< 200 nm), gamma and electromagnetic radiation, exposure to various atomic species and loaded particle (in various concentrations depending on altitude and solar activity, i.e. AO-flux = 4.5x10-16 atoms/cm2s), the impact with micrometeorites and fragments of space ("space debris"). Final Requirements matrix for the composite box that hosts electronics in microsatellite, developed within the project ADCOSSPA.
Conclusions : Phase III objectives were achieved, establishing operating conditions for spatial structures and bringing the contributions to establish final requirements that electronics housing for the microsatellite, made of composite materials in the project ADCOSSPA must respond. |
Property |
Value (RT) |
Standard |
Value (120°C) |
0° Flexural Strength |
910 MPa |
ISO 178 |
840 MPa |
0° Flexural Strength |
49 GPa |
ISO 178 |
47 GPa |
0° Tensile Strength |
760 MPa |
ISO 527-4 |
710 MPa |
0° Tensile Modulus |
59 MPa |
ISO 527-4 |
58 GPa |
0° Compressive Strength |
800 MPa |
EN 2850 |
710 MPa |
0° Compressive Modulus |
48 GPa |
EN 2850 |
41 GPa |
±45° In-Plane Shear Strength |
104 MPa |
EN 14129 |
85 MPa |
±45° In-Plane Shear Modulus |
G₁₂=4GPa |
EN 14129 |
3.9 GPa |
0° Interlaminar Shear Strength |
XILLS=74 MPa |
DMS 2144 |
64 MPa |
Materials used for the developed structural design meet the requirements of ECSS-Q-ST-70-02C and ASTM E595 (developed by NASA) standards concerning the outgassing phenomena for the materials used in space applications. The analysed samples showed a total mass loss (TMP[g cm-2]) <1% and an amount of collected condensed volatile substances (CVCM) less than 0.1%.
In order to ensure a high value of the thermal conductivity of the heat dissipation released by the electronic units, was used a second type of carbon fiber (λ=1000 [W/mK]) as reinforcing phase of the thermoset matrix (cyanat ester).
Tanatalum foil (thikness of 0.08 mm) symmetrical integrated (embeded) in the composite structure (forming a hybrid structure), in order to increase the ionizing radiation resistance (γ).
The aluminium AA 6082-T6 ribs are used to integrate the space structure in the microsatellite to stiffen the structure and to ensure (ionized) radiations shielding and the thermal transfer in vacuum, required for heat dissipation released by the elecronic units of the microsatellite
The structure was partially validated for the impact: Space debris: impact speed: 10 km/s, impact direction:45° from the normal of impacted surface, impactor density: 2.0 g/cm3. Thermal cycling strength was carried through exposure to 10 cycles of 100 minutes [-100;+100°C], in the climatic chamber, Hrel=0%, but in the absence of advanced vacuum environment (critical condition). After exposure the structure showed no degradation or significat structural changes. The exposure period was limited, thus, the stability and dimensional integrity of the structure wasn't damaged. The thermal conductivity of the structure has not been experimental determined. CTE (coefficient of thermal expansion) of the CFRP basic structure is 0.125x10-6 /K-1, ensuring the necessary dimensional stability, although, a critical issue in the project is the difference between the composite CTE and the metallic inserts CTE (tantalum foil, AA6082-T6 ribs) that can lead to tensions at the interfece during the polymerization process.
Radiation: The level of radiation on low orbit (LEO) at 600 - 900 km altitude: Electrons: 40 [keV] - 5 [MeV], based on AE-8 model; Protons: 100 [keV] - 200 [MeV], based on AP-8 model; X-ray: 0,1 - 10 [keV], according to solar eruptions, from photons with energies of 1-3 [keV]; Photons (Bremsstrahlung): made by radiation deceleration inside the material, contributes to degradation of material coatings; UV: FUV (far ultraviolet): 0,1 [W/m2] or 0,007% of solar electromagnetic radiation; NUV (near ultraviolets): 118 [W/m2] or 8,7% of solar electromagnetic radiation. Neutron bombing: creates collisions that produce punctual defects and material structure deployments. At high energies, they can lead to metallic or nemetallic material brittleness and their expansion, limiting their potential Gamma rays are absorbed by high atomic number and high density materials, but the most important criteria is which determines the material degradation is weight/area rate. Alpha and beta rays are less critical for polymeric materials, because they can be film shielded. Electromagnetic shielding as well as exposure, abrasion due to atomic species and charged particles, especially oxygen atoms, have been studied during this phase.
1.4. CAD Design of the mold for the satellite electronic housing mechanical structure
Exemple: CAD Model mpuld for "L" shape composite component
Mould material: Necuron 701. The selection criteria's: coeficient of thermal expansion CTE, colose to the one of the processed material (CFRP), in order to avoid stress concentrations do to CTE materials mismach, which can aprea during processing; high thermal resistance (polymerization process takes place at 160°C); easy mechanical operations and precision; thermal cycling resitance 9fatigue0; low density (mobility during manufacturing process).
1.5. Customized structural materials Design
Results are integrated in the section 1.3 presentation, above.
1.6. Laboratory testing of the proposed materials for structural and mechanical characterization
30 structural configurations were developed as laminates and samples with thicknesses of 2 mm using autoclave technology and afterwards tested in different regimes. The developed structures were examined before and after exposure to gamma radiations (from 10 to 500 Gy, Ce137 source with 0.4 KGrey/h) to determine the aging effect on the material microstructure and morphology; glass transition temperature (Tg) which sets the maximum temperature of the structure during service ; thermal conductivity (k) ; specific heat (c) ; thermal expansion coefficient (CTE) ; surface properties of the material (adherence, adhesive strength) ; tribological characteristics (friction coefficient/resistance, wear resistance) ; mechanical performances (static regime).
Several type of tests and analysis were performed : mechanical tests (shortly described in section 1.3 above) ; thermogravimetric analysis and dynamic differential calorimetry (TG-DSC) according to SR-EN 11357 : 2000 ; thermal diffusivity analysis, thermal conductivity analysis and specific heat analysis, thermal expansion coefficient analysis where it has been observed that an increase of radiation dose determines a decrease of temperature at which phase transformations in composite takes place, but in the same time the thermal transformation range become wider.
1.7. Preliminary manufacturing process- work protocol
The mould preparation operations were defined: grinding, cleaning, applying gelcoat, planarity and roughness measurement, etc., components (CF(1,2)RP structures: "L", "U", front plate): dimensions, structural design, structural or assembly elements, ribs positioning (number of plies, dimensions, sequence, etc.); main structural materials: materials (Tantalum foil, CF(1,2)RP composite, Aluminum ribs). CF(1,2)RP composite: number of plies, reinforcing thermoset resin volumetric fraction, ply thickenss, fiber orientation, ply dimensions, tantalum foil, mechanical and chemical surface treatment (adherence to the main composite materials structure, aluminum ribs/stiffners, dimensional control after mechanical operations, positioning within the structure, assembly method, etc. Likewise operations and processes: lay-up, vacuum bagging (basic and auxiliary materials) and curing cycle (autoclave technology), were defined.
Management and diseemination
Two technical meetings were organized: No.6/09.05.2014 and No.7/31.07.2014. The webpage of the project ADCOSSPA was updated (accesible on http://www.comoti.ro, in romanian and english) with the most recent results of the project. The ADCOSSPA team participated to the annual conference organized by contracting authority ROSA, "Romanina Space Week", 12-16 May 2014, bucharest, Romania.
Papers and conferences:
- scientific paper "Equipment Design and Structural Analysis of CFRP Electronics Housing vs. Aluminum Electronics Housing for an ADPMS" autori: Sorin Draghici, Florin Baciu, Raluca Voicu, Anton Hadar la conferinta ICSAAM 2013, The 5th International Conference on Structural Analysis of Advanced Materials 23 - 26 September 2013, Island of Kos, Grecia.
- scientific paper "Influence of advanced vacuum and temperature variations on the behavior of subassemblies of a satellite" Sorin Draghici, Florin Baciu, Raluca Voicu, Anton Hadar la conferinta 6th International Conference "Biomaterials, Tissue, Engineering&Medical Devices", 17-20 September 2014, Constanta, Romania
- scientific paper "Modelarea comportamentului la lansare a unui subansamblu din componenta unui satelit" Sorin Draghici, Florin Baciu, Raluca Voicu, Anton Hadar, Academia Oamenilor de Stiinta din Romania, Proceeding Sesiunea stiintifica de Primavara, 9 May 2014
- scientific paper "Structuri din materiale compozite avansate dezvoltate prin tehnologii performante pentru industrii de varf: aeronautica si spatiul la Insitutul Na?ional de Cercetare-Dezvoltare Turbomotoare COMOTI" Stiinta si Tehnica magazine, no.41 November /2014
Conclusions:
The objectives of Phase IV have been achieved. Based on the results from Phase III of the project, after establishing the final specific set of requirements for the space structure which integrates the electronic units in a microsatellite, the structural design and geometry (Final Design) has been defined and the methodology for designing the space composite structure has been created including the constrains for radiation shielding, first natural vibration frequency, structural integrity, electric resistivity and in the same time to limit the shape distortions generated by thermal loads (thermal cycles). Composite and metallic material selection has been performed for the space structure; different types of material configuration were tested, followed by material purchase. Validations of the structural design and of the selected materials for the space structure have been achieved during Phase IV, based on numerical simulations (FEA) and on the results from laboratory tests. Starting from the optimal design (CAD of structure elements), the mould required for the manufacturing process of the composite space structure has been designed. Likewise, during the Phase IV of the project, the preliminary manufacturing protocol for the mechanical compositespace structure hosting the electronics of a microsatellite, has been defined.